Nice Slice
★ 4.6 · 254 reviews Toronto Opened 2026
Slice counter on a quiet Borden Street corner
No dining room, no fuss, just a counter cutting slices on a corner ringed by houses. Nice Slice landed at eighteen on Toronto Life's list, and the crust is why: the dough gets a long ferment that shows in every bite.
Grab a slice and eat it on the curb. Most nights it's sold out by eight.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Samuel Chang 19 reviews · Local Guide 4 August 2026
The slice of pizza is indeed a "Nice Slice". Much like Mac's Pizza, the slices are thin, crispy, and packed with flavour. I tried the vodka pepperoni slice, and it was outstanding. I’m already looking forward to coming back to sample more of the menu. They have a small patio that's perfect for enjoying your pizza outdoors, along with some indoor seating if you prefer to eat inside. If you're a pizza lover, Nice Slice deserves a spot near the top of your must-visit list.
-
Considerate Food Tasting 39 reviews · Local Guide 18 July 2026
A thin-crust New York style slice with a decent tail flop and some interesting topping options. The shop is a decent size with self serve water if you sit in. The staff are friendly and helpful. We got the pickle and the sausage+rapini which are great as slices but for us a bit too much as a full pizza. Next time will try the pepperoni!
-
Don B 83 reviews · Local Guide 16 July 2026
Holy! This place deserve its flowers! The pizza is delicious. Vodka pep and Zaatar pizza really knocked it out! A 12$ wine glass seems like a decent price for Toronto, but at 16$ with a wine glass and a slice, thats a major combo!! Super fast service and the place is a vibe! Final note, DONT SKIP ON THAT ZAATAR PIZZA 🍕
-
James M 42 reviews · Local Guide 18 June 2026
I've been meaning to come by and try these guys out for a while but am rarely in that neighbourhood these days. But I will definitely be making my way to that neighbourhood more often just for them. Instantly amongst the best Pizzas in the city with (in no particular order) Badialli, Mac's, North of Brooklyn, Acute, Gracie's, Bar Sugo etc when it comes to Toronto style slices. Their dough, cheese and sauce all hold up and are the foundation for any good pizza, the ingredients all stand out and can be identified individually well working together harmoniously. Well done guys, I'm sure you'll have line ups around the corner once summer proper arrives.
-
Jeremy Goldfarb 53 reviews · Local Guide 5 June 2026
I’ve done my pizza research. Toronto, NYC, elsewhere. With confidence, this is amongst the best slices in Toronto. It’s insane that Badiali has a 45 min wait and I just walked into Nice Slice and got a 12/10 slice immediately. You can debate the rankings but this place is in the mix. Good vibe. Nice staff. Incredible pizza. The picture is of a half slice bc I couldn’t wait. Pepperoni was awesome. Vodka sauce was the standout.
People also visited
Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.