El Pescaito de Getsemaní
★ 5.0 · 173 reviews Cartagena Opened 2024
Grilled fish, caught with a conscience
The fish on the grill at El Pescaito comes from boats working under a local sustainability agreement, not whatever's cheapest at the market that morning. Everything on the menu comes straight off the coals.
It's a short walk from the walled city on Calle Larga, and the prices match Getsemaní, not the marked-up Centro menus next door.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Brian Tanner 22 reviews · Local Guide 23 July 2026
One of my favorite meals of my entire South America trip. El Pescaito de Getsemaní is exactly the kind of restaurant I hope to find when I travel. It’s a small seafood restaurant run by its two owners, who are incredibly welcoming and clearly passionate about what they’re creating. The menu is intentionally small and focused on sustainably sourced seafood. I started with the tropical ceviche, followed by the whole grilled róbalo. The fish was simply prepared with olive oil, perfectly grilled, and so fresh that it really didn’t need anything else. I finished with the mango mousse dessert, which had a rich dark chocolate center and was light, balanced, and an excellent way to end the meal. Beyond the food, what really stood out was the atmosphere. This feels like a genuine neighborhood restaurant where the owners are cooking, serving, greeting guests, and making sure everyone has a great experience. If you’re staying in Getsemaní and appreciate fresh seafood, thoughtful cooking, and supporting independent owner-operated restaurants, don’t miss this place.
-
Noah 15 reviews · Local Guide 21 July 2026
This was no doubt the best food we’ve had in Colombia! If you love fish you have to come here. The flavors were really balanced and refined and they showed the fresh fish before the dishes were prepared. The owners are very friendly and the service is excellent as well. No doubt a must eat in Cartagena.
-
Isabel Davidson 28 reviews · Local Guide 25 May 2026
This meal was one of the best meals we have ever had!! The fish and other ingredients are unbelievably fresh, and the flavours are so so delicious. I can’t recommend this place enough, the staff are lovely and the food is just exquisite! The fish arepas and tuna were such a highlight.
-
Caz Milford 102 reviews · Local Guide 7 April 2026
We just happened to be walking past this restaurant yesterday, and having seen the menu decided to pop in for late lunch. What greeted us was incredible hospitality, and delicious fresh sustainable fish. The ceviche was for me the star of the show, I loved the grapefruit with it, and how it was served, and the grilled robaldo was fabulous too.
-
Danylo 141 reviews · Local Guide 21 March 2026
It was expensive and portions were small, hut the ceviche here was the only truly excellent plate I had in cartagena. Can’t miss. Octopus was tasty as well but potatoes were a bit dry.
People also visited
Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.






