Casa Paolino
★ 3.8 · 35 reviews Capri Opened 2 May 2026
The Paolino family's second address, five minutes from the Piazzetta
The Bomba di Paolino made the original restaurant's name at Marina Grande. Now it's on the menu again, a five minute walk from the Piazzetta, inside the former Villa Margherita spaces at Hotel La Canasta.
The room is smaller and warmer than the lemon garden original, built through a collaboration between the Paolino and Hotel Mamela families. Newer plates lean into contemporary technique, but this reads like a neighborhood address, not a destination restaurant.
Good to know
- Book the original Paolino Lemontrees at Marina Grande if you want the lemon garden, Casa Paolino is the indoor, year-round sibling.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Travel “FoodMax” M.C. 243 reviews · Local Guide 17 July 2026
Casa Paolino offers a dining experience very similar to its famous sibling, Da Paolino at Lemon Tree. The atmosphere is elegant, the setting is beautiful, and expectations are naturally high. Unfortunately, the food didn’t quite justify the premium prices. The fresh scampi were the highlight of the meal—excellent quality, sweet, fresh, and perfectly prepared. The spaghetti alle vongole were also enjoyable, with well-cooked pasta and good flavor, even if they weren’t particularly memorable. On the other hand, the veal fillet was disappointing. It lacked tenderness and depth of flavor, especially considering the price point. The calamari served with potatoes were probably the weakest dish we ordered, with an odd combination that simply didn’t work. Dessert was another letdown: the ice cream tasted industrial and lacked the richness you would expect from a restaurant of this reputation. Overall, Casa Paolino feels like an average restaurant benefiting from the prestige of the Paolino name. While a few dishes stand out, several others miss the mark, making the overall experience inconsistent. Service was professional, but prices are definitely on the high side for what is delivered on the plate. If you’re looking for the true Paolino experience, the original Lemon Tree still has the edge. Casa Paolino is worth trying once, but I wouldn’t rush back.
-
N 8 reviews 8 July 2026
We had amazing dinner, I am so surprised from the bed reviews. First of all, the food was amazing! We had lobster pasta and fish and both was amazing, the portions are so big and really delicious! The service is one of the best, Alessio made our dinner great, he was so attentive and super polite, super nice guy! Totally recommending the place. For me it was even better than the Da Paolino Lemontrees, because it feels so relaxed and no rush for anything!
-
Te Kucne Stvari 2 reviews 15 June 2026
I would like to start with a good part: the location is great. 10/10. Colors and how is all designed from toilets to chairs - very good. But, my owerall experience would be 3/5 stars because: there was no music at all (not even a light guitar music) and our reservation was at 20:30… lightning was too bright for dinner time, and tables too close. The food was ok. Wine list is very good one.
-
Pietro Cammerini 131 reviews · Local Guide 14 June 2026
We just went to Paolino Lemontrees yesterday so will do a comparison Ambiance is not nearly as nice although there is a cow Service is similar although the environment is a bit less festive Menu is very similar to that of the classic Paolino but a little bit smaller. The food is just as good! Really good dishes all around. We loved the lemon caprese as desert! Overall positive experience but definitely go to Paolino lemon tress first as that is the better one
-
Jonathan Schaff 16 reviews · Local Guide 10 May 2026
Went back twice on our trip it was so good!!
People also visited
June 2024Concettina ai Tre Santi CapriCapri Town & Piazzetta
May 2025Santina CapriCapri Town & PiazzettaVico Pizza & WineJuly 2025Vico Pizza & WineCapri Town & PiazzettaA-Ma-Re Capri7 June 2024A-Ma-Re CapriAnacapri
15 May 2026Zuma CapriAnacapri
June 2025Luce CapriCapri Town & Piazzetta
16 April 2026Casa Tua CapriCapri Town & Piazzetta Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.