La Vecchia Signora
★ 4.5 · 314 reviews San Juan del Sur Opened Opening date unknown
Wood-fired pizza that owns San Juan del Sur's main drag
The prosciutto pizza is the one everyone orders, pulled from a wood-fired oven by an Italian owner who's clearly more devoted to Juventus than most fans back in Turin. It shows in the decor as much as the crust.
The room is small and fills up fast at peak dinner hours, but it's family-friendly and turns tables quickly enough that the wait pays off. Several pizzerias share this stretch of street. This one's still the name locals default to.
Good to know
- The prosciutto pizza gets singled out most in reviews.
- Small dining room, expect a wait during peak dinner hours.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Mikey P 217 reviews · Local Guide 5 April 2026
Great Italian style pizza, really good dough and super fresh tasting toppings.
-
Lola Reunion 68 reviews · Local Guide 30 March 2026
The pizzas are excellent—honestly some of the best I’ve had in Central America so far. The only downside was the service. The staff didn’t feel particularly friendly, and our waiter seemed a bit annoyed when we changed our mind about one of the pizzas while ordering. It made us feel like we were bothering him, which took away a bit from the overall experience.
-
Max Powers 109 reviews · Local Guide 24 February 2026
Good pizza. Very poor service. It’s so loud at night with the drunks that you cant hear yourself think. Perhaps doing a take out is a good option Small place but an actual wood oven!
-
jayme oshaben 35 reviews · Local Guide 2 February 2026
We got pizza from here three times during our stay and everytime it was delicious. The dough is perfect and the sauce is tasty. Lots of options. Highly recommend for a pizza fix!
-
Craig Dworkin 18 reviews · Local Guide 11 April 2025
This no frills pizza place was absolutely terrific and I think the entire bill was $5 U.S. The pizza had an excellent crisp and burnt in all the right spots. Highly recommend to anyone coming to visit.
People also visited
Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.
Terraza Mi Viejo San Juan
Studio Cafe Bar & Grill
Dumplings Aqui
Machete Market Cafe
Sauced Pizza
Dale Pues
Peace & Cake