Alfi Pizza
★ 4.5 · 176 reviews Cape Town Opened February 2025
New Haven pizza lands on Main Road
The white clam pie is the one to order at Alfi. Coal-fired, oblong, charred at the edges the way Neapolitan purists would call a mistake, this is New Haven-style pizza and it barely exists outside Connecticut, let alone South Africa.
Slices run big. Two people can split a pie and a salad and still leave full.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Zee Kitty 3 reviews 25 July 2026
Absolutely amazing EVERYTHING! the food, the staff, the kindest most patient staff. Definitely the best service I’ve received in all 6 years living in Cape Town. Tsitsi , Chantel , Oscar and Constance are the exceptional. Their work ethic and passion is outstanding. Definitely recommend ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
-
Scott Doyne 69 reviews · Local Guide 27 May 2026
Delicious! Had the margherita pizza and eggplant fold over. Very little seating inside.
-
Matthew Burchell 58 reviews · Local Guide 29 April 2026
The key to a great pizza is a light, slightly charred, well-structured crust, and interesting, thoughtful, minimalist toppings. Alfi Pizza does both brilliantly. As a South African, I’m often frustrated by the poor quality of most pizza in South Africa - thin, flavourless crusts that are more like crackers than dough, and overloaded with toppings with a “more is more” mentality. If that’s what you enjoy, don’t come to Alfi Pizza - you’ll hate it. But if you want pizza that’s made properly with interesting toppings, it’s the place for you. A lot of the more negative reviews on Google (e.g. complaining about the charred crusts) seem to come from people who have never tasted real pizza, only the bad South African kind. If you’re vegetarian, then Alfi Pizza is great for you - plenty of good vegetarian options.
-
Azrah Rylands 1 review 18 April 2026
One of the best pizza places I’ve ever been to in my life with the kindest staff.
-
Adam Gąsior 88 reviews · Local Guide 22 January 2026
Super pizza and great service! Nduja and Fughi were amazing. One of the best we have ever ate. Highly recommend!
People also visited
Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.







