Trattoria Maria
★ 4.8 · 45 reviews Sheffield Opened 2026
Sicilian trattoria from the team behind Bench
Jack Wakelin and Tom Aronica traded natural wine and small plates for something more traditional. Maria leans into Aronica's Sicilian roots, running a galley kitchen that turns out seasonal small plates on Wellington Street in the Heart of the City development.
The opening offer, a £5 negroni, says a lot about the ambition here. This is a restaurant built for regulars, not just one big night, from a duo whose earlier Sheffield spots both earned national attention.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
John Adler 34 reviews · Local Guide 5 August 2026
Fabulous first visit to Maria, but won’t be our last. Great Italian themed food, miles away from your standard pizza and pasta. Buzzy atmosphere (even though it was early evening midweek) and great friendly, warm professional service. Superb from start to finish.
-
Amy Coulthard 18 reviews · Local Guide 19 July 2026
Amazing food, service and ambience! They also went out of their way to make my friends birthday special! Thank you so much, can’t wait to come back!
-
Adrian Glover 74 reviews · Local Guide 3 July 2026
Amazing Food Brilliant service 5 stars
-
Diane Tomlinson 28 reviews · Local Guide 3 July 2026
First visit and we were highly impressed. Service was very good and the food was delicious amazing flavours. Can’t wait to return. The zero Alcohol negroni has the right kick.
-
Sarah Heward 5 reviews 7 June 2026
We visited Maria for the first time on Saturday night. We got a very warm welcome & the atmosphere was just lovely. All of the dishes were exceptional & the flow of them being served was just right. The tiramisu the best I’ve ever tasted. I can highly recommend the Gavi, all of the drinks were great. We will definitely be back. Thank-you to all of the team!
People also visited
7 November 2025Shaanti TownSharrow Vale
August 2026Cats Café-BarBroomhill
20 June 2026Earl's YardCity Centre
6 February 2026Alura Turkish Grill & LoungeEcclesall Road
22 September 2025Tavern on the QuaysCity Centre
2025Six and a HalfSharrow Vale
June 2024La BottegaCity Centre
27 March 2026ForbiciCity Centre Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.