Forbidden Pizza
★ 4.7 · 569 reviews New Orleans Opened 5 December 2024
Brooklyn-style pies the Baudiers couldn't find here
Beau and Nicole Baudier couldn't find the pizza they wanted in New Orleans, so they opened Forbidden Pizza on 5 December 2024, on Baronne Street. The name is a joke about forbidden fruit.
Brooklyn-style pies, wide slices, burrata and basil on the one worth ordering first. It opened in the middle of the city's pizza boom, one more name in a crowded field for slices.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Rhys Williams 11 reviews · Local Guide 23 July 2026
When you grow up in the northeast, your expectations for pizza and hoagies are very high, so when I moved to the south I was disappointed to say the least, and chronically so. Finally there’s a place in New Orleans that makes high-quality, New York / Northeast-style thin crust pizza. There are so many good options to choose from. Don’t sleep on the cookies and gelato either. The bar is also really nice, serving up great cocktails.
-
Nicola R 191 reviews · Local Guide 23 July 2026
What a spectacular place. I was starving and craving a slice. Happened upon this place by good fortune. Delicious pizza by the slice. Super friendly staff. Great atmosphere. Whether traveling solo or hanging out with friends, this is a wonderful spot to hang at and enjoy good pizza and great hospitality.
-
Allison Bauser 36 reviews · Local Guide 3 July 2026
Forbidden Pizza is a standout spot for anyone craving authentic New York–style pizza. The crust is perfectly crisp on the outside with just the right chew, and the sauce and toppings come together in a simple but genuinely delicious way that feels true to classic NY slices. Beyond the food, the atmosphere is just as memorable. The interior bar area features bold, Medusa-themed artwork and graphics that give the space a unique, almost mythic vibe. It adds a creative edge that sets the restaurant apart from typical pizza spots. Between the high-quality pizza and the visually striking design, Forbidden Pizza delivers both great flavor and a distinctive dining experience worth coming back for.
-
Taylor 8 reviews · Local Guide 29 June 2026
This pizza spot has become my go to! It's so easy to grab pizza by the slice and it's some of the best I've ever had. They also have an awesome lounge area with open seating and a bar. My fave slices have been the Forbidden Fruit and Italian Stallion. It's perfect for thin crust New York style lovers. The staff are always friendly as well.
-
E S 255 reviews · Local Guide 28 June 2026
Dave Portnoy's 8.3 felt like a fair score. Forbidden Pizza is definitely in the same conversation as Zee's and Pizza Delicious. Personally, I'd still give the edge to Zee's and Pizza Delicious, even though they received lower One Bite scores. The crust was thin, light, and great flavor. My only disappointment was that it was missing that crisp I really look for in a great pizza. Still, it's definitely one of the better pizza in New Orleans and well worth trying. 👍🏾👍🏾
People also visited
23 October 202434 Restaurant & BarCentral Business District
November 2025Nanami Sushi Diner & OnigiriGarden District
June 2026HolywaterFrench Quarter
August 2025Paulie's DelicatessenCarrollton
6 September 2024Bub's Burgers Grab & GoFreret
2026BonafriedBayou St. John
June 2026Royal Woodfired PizzaMarigny
February 2025Brutto AmericanoCentral Business District Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.