Blackboard Eatery
★ 5.0 · 26 reviews Isla Mujeres Opened December 2025
House-baked sourdough, thick sandwiches, that hummus plate
The sourdough here is the whole point. Blackboard Eatery bakes its own and builds the menu around it: thick sandwiches, juicy burgers, salads, and a hummus plate regulars order almost without thinking.
It fills a real gap on this stretch of Avenida Rueda Medina, something lighter than a seafood dinner but more filling than a taco stand. Get the blueberry sourdough if it's on the breakfast menu, it's already got its own following on the island.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
TopekaMike 12 reviews · Local Guide 26 July 2026
food was great! loved seeing all of the art made by the chef Addy too. we did burgers and fries and tacos they all were fantastic and well played! A new favorite for us.
-
Jamie Knight 35 reviews · Local Guide 14 June 2026
Delicious ribeye sandwich on homemade sourdough. Fantastic burgers and drinks, especially good margaritas. The house made salsa picante is amazing. We will definitely be back. Highly recommend. Excellent owners who deserve all the support. Xo
-
Kohler Stevens 48 reviews · Local Guide 13 June 2026
Incredible food! This is a must when visiting the island. I’d highly recommend the steak sandwich. It’s one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had!
-
Nicole 13 reviews · Local Guide 17 May 2026
We stayed on the Island in April and were right across the street from here. Everything here was delicious. The mint ginger lemonade was my absolute favorite. Don't even get me started on the green sauce they make. Its got a kick to it but its soo delicious. If I ever return to the Island I will absolutely return here.
-
Denise Kingsley 23 reviews · Local Guide 19 April 2026
WOW, do not miss out eating here while on Isla. They make their own bread, the brisket and burgers are to die for!!! And the fries, fresh cut with a spicey twist, so delicious. Highly recommend, you won't be disappointed. Drinks are awesome too. Check it out.
People also visited
April 2026Los Meros MerosSalina ChicaParadise Burger & BarOctober 2025Paradise Burger & BarCentroUlan Eatery2024Ulan EateryPunta SurAreia Beach Club23 March 2024Areia Beach ClubPunta SurLoretta's Restaurant & Beach ClubNovember 2025Loretta's Restaurant & Beach ClubPunta Sur
March 2025YaakunCentro
March 2024El MexicanoCentro
March 2026Simone RestaurantCentro Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.