El Mexicano
★ 4.7 · 429 reviews Isla Mujeres Opened March 2024
Homemade Mexican cooking on a strip full of fusion menus
Skip the beach-facing fusion plates lining Avenida Hidalgo. El Mexicano cooks the way a family table in central Mexico does, straightforward and unfussy, and it serves lunch through dinner.
It took over the old Raw Bar by Fish&Gin space, but there's nothing fishy on this menu. Just traditional recipes done properly, which is rarer than you'd think on this tourist-heavy street.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Tania 43 reviews · Local Guide 3 August 2026
This restaurant is delicious! I recommend trying to snag a table in the back, it's a whole new world, a little more peace and quiet. The food was fantastic! Truly recommend it if you're looking for something authentic and more private. The best part, the chips ate freshly made!
-
Chandani Amin 18 reviews · Local Guide 11 June 2026
Had a great meal here - was a bit worried about eating on the main strip where everything is a bit pricy but this place was amazing and staff so friendly and helpful. We shared the guacamole (really, really good and big) and the local fish dish Tikin Xic (takes a bit of time to prepare fresh but so worth the wait with amazing mezcalitas and it’s a lot of fish!). Plus super juicy tacos and they adapted another dish to be vegetarian for a friend. Garden out back is a nice spot. Deffo recommend.
-
Kirby Daniel 8 reviews · Local Guide 7 June 2026
Best guacamole we had on the island. Standard Isla pricing but portions are large so sharing is where it’s at. BOGO margs from 5-6pm.
-
Lora Moore 33 reviews · Local Guide 30 May 2026
Highly recommend for Aguachile and Ceviche!! the fish in the ceviche was incredibly fresh, you can really tell. Same with the aguachile. Flavors were amazing. Attentive service. Also restaurant is really cute and clean.
-
Brian Christie 6 reviews May 2026
Great bar, the food was delicious. In particular the birria and the guacamole on the nachos. The staff were super friendly and the bill was very reasonable considering the amount we had. Would definitely recommend! Good for an aperol spritz.
People also visited
30 December 2025Mamita's BurgerCentro
July 2024Mahi-Mahi Sea Food TacosLa Gloria
April 2026Los Meros MerosSalina Chica
December 2025Blackboard EaterySalina ChicaParadise Burger & BarOctober 2025Paradise Burger & BarCentroUlan Eatery2024Ulan EateryPunta SurAreia Beach Club23 March 2024Areia Beach ClubPunta SurLoretta's Restaurant & Beach ClubNovember 2025Loretta's Restaurant & Beach ClubPunta Sur Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.