Original Tony's
★ 4.6 · 195 reviews Brighton Opened October 2025
Seventy-two-hour dough, a parmesan crust and cocktails in jars
That parmesan crust is the whole point. Toby Cackett ferments his dough for seventy-two hours before it hits the oven, coming out as fourteen-inch pizzas with a crisp cheese rim you'll fight someone for. Cocktails arrive in jars, and a bat-signal logo lights up the pavement once the sun's down.
Trafalgar Street runs steep from the station into the North Laine, lined with independent shops that have been there for decades. The kitchen opens from four most days, so come hungry after work rather than for lunch.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Alan Spink 7 reviews 6 August 2026
What a joy to find a local independent pizza restaurant. Wonderful tastes and smells and huge pizzas. I’m giving 5 stars for the food and staff but please get some comfy furniture for your generationally challenged clientele. Whilst we still have a couple of teeth left we do enjoy a good pizza. But our bony bums need external padding. See you again soon (god and the NHS willing). 🙏🙏🙏
-
Matt Hayes 112 reviews · Local Guide 30 June 2026
What a place! True Italian pizza parlour vibes. The menu was amazing and personally I feel it was fantastic value for money. Ruby went above and beyond and made us feel so welcomed. A fantastic birthday treat and pardon peppers were unreal. Top it all off they had Inchusa Unfiltered which is ridiculous hard to find in the UK so a little slice of Sardinia 20mins walk from Brighton seafront
-
Jazmine Leigh 34 reviews · Local Guide 11 May 2026
Totally worth the hype! We luvvvv Tony’s! Came here for our anniversary dinner and it made our evening! Such delicious pizzas, padron peppers in vodka sauce were to dieeee for and great spicy margs! Can’t wait to come back again
-
Louise Tamadon-Nejad 48 reviews · Local Guide 11 May 2026
Happened to walk by on Saturday afternoon, spontaneously popped in. It was fairly quiet at that point, but it was the calm before the Saturday night storm! The girls working were charming and smiley, prompt and efficient. The atmosphere was buzzy with good music and vibes. Lots of people stopping by in hope of a table or collecting takeaway. We shared a pizza, it was sooo good. Great base, held its own perfectly and had a nice crisp crunch to it also. Tony's topping were a great choice as were the padron peppers that came with a romesco sauce. Wines were the perfect accompaniment, nice choice. Simple and rustic, almost felt like we were somewhere else.. Would like to go back and try more.
-
Anaïs Schlienger 353 reviews · Local Guide 10 April 2026
Great American pizza! Really got the pizza slice joint vibes, but elevated and more intimist. LOVED the mushroom smoked mascarpone one and the pear and blue cheese one (could have used more pears though).
People also visited
Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.







