Spread Bagelry

J Jenna Schuster 22 reviews · Local Guide 14 July 2026

As eating out is a luxury for us these days and I was looking forward to Spread bagels as a birthday treat, but it was sadly disappointing! After moving from Philly I was excited to learn a spot opened here. So I'm quite familiar with Spread bagels, but both kinds of the bagels we got here were extremely tough, with an 1/8" thick hard crust, like they were overcooked. I can even see it in others photos here. Reading the menus was difficult, especially before I got up to the cashier.

T Thomas Gilmore 64 reviews · Local Guide 5 July 2026

We enjoyed the cure which had a good amount of brisket, egg and bacon. The jalapeño spread on this was amazing. We also enjoyed the salted egg bagel with pistachio honey spread. Not too sweet. So good! Will definitely be back.

K Kevin Nguyen 65 reviews · Local Guide 7 June 2026

I love this place. I come here at least once every two weeks. It makes me feel like I’m in NYC. Introducing some colored bagels would do great here like for holidays or big events like Valentines Day, Rainbow for Pride, or Blue and Orange for the Knicks.

G Giantess 9 reviews 29 May 2026

I realize we are lacking for great bagels in this part of the country, but these are not the answer. They were out of multiple things I tried to order in the middle of the week first thing in the morning. I settled for an egg salt bagel with lox. One would expect a wood fired bagel to be flavorful, but it was flat. The lox was sliced way too thick to be enjoyable without cutting into smaller pieces. After being extremely underwhelmed by my sandwich I wanted to give them a fair shake and ordered a plain cinnamon raisin. I thought maybe all the toppings distracted from the bagel, but no. It was underwhelming and undercooked. Maybe the other locations are better?

E Evan McCarthy 8 reviews 28 April 2026

Delish coffee and bagel sandwich. Service was great, atmosphere was a step up. Comfortable, will absolutely come here again.