El Rinconcito Mexican
★ 4.7 · 237 reviews Key West Opened 2024
Real Mexican food, New Town prices
Skip Duval Street and head for the Overseas Market plaza on North Roosevelt Boulevard instead. This no-frills counter spot does tacos and Mexican staples without the tourist markup.
Locals rate it as one of the more affordable kitchens on the island. It's a storefront operation, not a sit-down restaurant, so expect simple tables and fast service rather than atmosphere.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Zack 7 reviews 13 July 2026
We made a carryout order for some tacos and we loved it. The homemade hot sauce is sooo good. So we came back for breakfast and had the breakfast burrito and again delicious.
-
House of Klein 6 reviews 30 June 2026
We’re new to the area and have been on the hunt for a good Mexican restaurant. Walked inside, dining area is small but cozy! Immediately we’re impressed by the freshly fried chips, the cheese dip was good to the last drop and the guacamole was good as well. Food came out in a timely fashion and we inhaled it! It was delicious. We will most certainly be back!
-
Gigi Rodriguez 8 reviews June 2026
If you’re thinking about trying this place, do it! Everything we ordered was amazing. The rice was some of the best I’ve had, and the michelada was absolutely perfect. Honestly, we didn’t have a single bad thing on the table. Just be prepared to wait a little bit since it’s a smaller restaurant, but it’s 100% worth it. The food comes out hot, fresh, and full of flavor. You can tell they take pride in what they’re serving. The service was great, and the whole experience was fantastic. I’m from Texas and know good Mexican food when I taste it, and I would definitely come back here again. Highly recommend!
-
Conrad Mazon 5 reviews 5 February 2026
I'm from Chicago and was looking for a menudo. This place came up and once I tried it. It didn't disappoint. Great food! Will come back
-
Jesenia Morales 6 reviews 3 November 2025
I came here on a recommendation from my son who had talked about how good their food was. Well he wasn't wrong! If you are looking for authentic Mexican food with great service this is your place.
People also visited
2025Dorada Key WestNew Town
2024White Street PizzaNew Town
2026Dragon & RoosterOld Town
2 April 2026Lolita's Coastal CocinaOld Town
4 December 2025SM OnlywoodOld Town
July 2025Square Grouper Bar & Grill Key WestOld Town
13 January 2026Doc's on DuvalOld Town
February 2026Fishwife Restaurant & Raw BarBahama Village Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.