White Street Pizza

M Mark in Key West 25 reviews · Local Guide 22 July 2026

I stopped in to check out the happy hour. I was not disappointed. The staff were friendly, the food was delicious, and the beer was cold. What more could you ask for. So many great looking choices on the menu, friendly people behind the bar and a great island vibe…. Definite return for sure!!

J James P. 122 reviews · Local Guide June 2026

A local hideaway in Key West! The food is delicious and it has a very cool, old fashioned ice cream parlor vibe! The chocolate key lime pie was to die for! Loved it all around!!!

K Kristen McNamara 3 reviews 13 April 2026

Can’t say enough about how amazing this place is! High quality ingredients, incredible flavors in everything. I had the Boston Bibb salad with chicken AGAIN, and it’s definitely one of my favorite salads in Key West. My boyfriend had the meatball sub and was licking his fingers then the plate, it’s safe to say we will be coming back regularly. Our server Jennifer was outstanding as usual and we always enjoy visiting with Carl. 10/10, can’t wait to come back!

K Keys Conscious Collective 1 review · Local Guide 25 March 2026

White Street Pizza is an absolute neighborhood gem! My team and I are regulars for pickup and delivery, and it’s my go-to spot for dinner with my bestie. The staff, food, and atmosphere are all incredible. What sets them apart is the quality—you're getting gourmet, fine-dining Italian flavors in a relaxed, welcoming local setting. It’s brilliant! Huge shoutout to Carl and the crew for always taking such great care of us.

J jared 83 reviews · Local Guide 24 March 2026

Stopped in today and was really impressed. Their 12‑inch meatball pizza is excellent — super flavorful with a great crust. The menu is concise and easy to navigate, and everything they serve is done really well. It’s a good spot for a daily lunch, and I’ll definitely be back.