Chrissy's Pizza
★ 4.5 · 579 reviews New York Opened October 2024
Pizza that doesn't taste like anyone else's in the city
New York does not lack for pizza, which makes it worth saying that Chrissy's does not taste like the rest of it. The shop sits on Nassau Avenue in Greenpoint and has built its name on the pies alone, no room, no concept.
It is a small operation and it behaves like one. Supply is finite, the menu is short, and the queue sorts itself out. This is the pizza people cross boroughs for, not the pizza they grab on the way home.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Joanna Felix 12 reviews 31 July 2026
Pretty good pizza, excellent sauce, however they are skimpy on the cheese, I had to double check if it had any…. Feels like only tomato sauce. For the price they should spread the cheese love.
-
Hidden Gem 316 reviews · Local Guide 22 June 2026
Finally got around to trying it after having it on my list for a couple of years. I hadn’t had the chance to make it out to Brooklyn before, but I’m so glad I finally did. The pizza was everything I imagined and more. We were the first ones to order, and it ended up being one of my favorite pizzas I’ve had to date. The crust was light and crispy, the sauce was packed with flavor, and every bite lived up to the hype. An absolute must-try in New York, and I can’t wait to come back.
-
Nicole Magath 12 reviews · Local Guide 10 June 2026
Holy heck. This place was out of this world. We got the hot white pie which was so flippin good - spicyness was spread out so well! But we also got their plain pie and it was legit the best I have ever had. Like, I have a childhood favorite place that I never thought any place could touch simply for the nostalgia factor - but this place did. It's pies only, no slices ... But no problem because you're going to want all of it. Plus, that means they're making everything hot and fresh for you! Everything else that passed by me looked absolutely delish and I am drooling to go back. 10/10 would 1000% recommend.
-
Kyle Delaney 7 reviews 5 June 2026
Pizza was fresh and made to order when ordered online. Will be returning and highly recommended. Make sure when ordering online that you come at that time because they make it for the exact time and pride themselves on it!
-
carlos borges 305 reviews · Local Guide June 2026
LEGENDARY flavor, ingredients, love, and excellence in this pizza. This is some of the most delicious and well crafted pizza on the planet. Nuff said. The sauce is bonkers. If you love sauce, then it's extraordinary here. So juicy. The cheese smacks. The crust is crispy and light. There's a touch in this pizza that calls me back for more. Its in the olive oil and the sauce for me. It all comes together in an cravable way. Bravo.
People also visited
Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.