Sailor & Siren
★ 4.8 · 59 reviews New York Opened July 2026
Lobster rolls off the family wharf in Maine
The lobster here skips the usual middlemen. It comes straight off the owners' family wharf in Maine, about as short a supply chain as a Brooklyn lunch counter can claim.
Rolls come buttered or with mayo, the debate that never ends. Hot dogs and whoopie pies round out the menu at this former pop-up turned Manhattan Avenue shop.
Good to know
- Rolls come either buttered or with mayo. Pick a side.
What guests say
Reviews by Google-
Vivianne Barretto 430 reviews · Local Guide 10 August 2026
Amazing Lobster Roll. Wonderful service and decent price for the quality and quantity of Lobster in the roll. The space is small. They have some tables outside, that helps. Cute decor. They sell merch also. I wish them the best of luck, they worked hard to get this brick and mortar up and running.
-
Michael Straky 343 reviews · Local Guide 7 August 2026
Very good, but definitely busy and chaotic! I really enjoyed the lobster roll that came in uni. The woman who butters and hands them out is sooooo friendly.
-
Ori Barnik 20 reviews · Local Guide 2 August 2026
Lives up to the hype. Top 3 (if not top) Lobster Roll I’ve ever had.
-
Jenny Z 10 reviews 2 August 2026
Best lobster roll in NY! Everyone was so welcoming and everything was so delicious! We also tried the lobster dip and the pocket pie - definitely recommend! So good we forgot to take pictures 😋
-
Nic Garcia 235 reviews · Local Guide 26 July 2026
One of the best lobster rolls ever! There’s an entire lobster in each roll. So buttery and delicious, tastes so fresh and succulent. I couldn’t be happier. Very friendly staff, small space with limited counter, worth every penny for a 2.5 hour round trip to get here.
People also visited
Thank you!
Thanks, we'll take a look.